Hayate The Combat Butler Wiki
All Contributors
Hina sama
A FANDOM User
• 4/18/2014

Plot hole?

I dont remember the exact chapter but I'm pretty sure that Hayate once called Alice: A-tan in front of Hina.. and Hina wanted to call Athena: A-tan too, so Hina should recognize Alice since she looks so much like Athena and she even heard Hayate call her A-tan... So is it a plot hole?

0 3
  • Upvote
  • Reply
Hina sama
0
• 4/18/2014

I believe your referring to Chapter 352, when everyone was sick at the Violet Mansion and yes you are right he did in fact call her "A-tan" in front of Hinagiku and everyone else, but I'm pretty certain Hinagiku wasn't really paying attention to him as she was coughing and trying to overcome her cold with "pure will power" as she mentioned earlier on in the chapter.

0
A FANDOM User
• 4/18/2014

Yes that right but after I read the chapter again, it has an other scene in chapter 445 where hayate called alice : A-tan in front of Hina and everyone. Maybe Hina just really doesn't pay any attention?

0
• 4/19/2014
209.197.147.183 wrote:
Yes that right but after I read the chapter again, it has an other scene in chapter 445 where hayate called alice : A-tan in front of Hina and everyone. Maybe Hina just really doesn't pay any attention?

Well that is true, he did call her "A-tan" in chapter 445. Then I guess it is possible that he might of been questioned by Hinagiku off screen about it, but seeing that this is Hayate no Gotoku! and how gullible the characters can be at times, I'm pretty certain that Hinagiku will realize that "A-tan" is Athena Tennousu in due time. 

Write a reply...