Hayate The Combat Butler Wiki
All Contributors
Hina sama
• 11/17/2013

Are the girls underweight?

Apparently, I compared the girls' weight and height on the body mass index and it shows that most of them are underweight (<18.5), some to the point of anorexia. The only one who seems to have a healthy BMI is Sonia (at 19.7).

Hinagiku and Saki: 17.3 (1.2 points short)

Maria: 16.7 (1.8 points short)

Nagi: 15.0 (3.5 points short)

Isumi: 14.4 (4.1 points short)

Ayumu: 17.8 (0.7 points short)

Izumi: 17.9 (0.6 points short)

Chiharu: 18.0 (0.5 points short)

Miki: 18.4 (0.1 points short)

Risa: 17.0 (1.5 points short)

Aika: 16.8 (1.7 points short)

0 3
  • Upvote
  • Reply
Hina sama
0
• 11/17/2013

It's true a BMI would say that the characters would be underweight/anorexic, but you have to put into consideration that the series takes place in Japan and people there do tend to weigh less due to their life style and diet.

Also you got to remember, this is a fictional series. So you shouldn't put too much thought into the characters weight or height. ^^;

0
A FANDOM User
• 11/17/2013
Hina sama wrote:
It's true a BMI would say that the characters would be underweight/anorexic, but you have to put into consideration that the series takes place in Japan and people there do tend to weigh less due to their life style and diet.

Also you got to remember, this is a fictional series. So you shouldn't put too much thought into the characters weight or height. ^^;

I know it's fiction but for Nagi and Isumi, it would seem unhealthy for the current weight relative to their height (would a Japanese 13-year old at 138 cm weight 63 pounds in real life without suffering from anorexia). Hayate's is at 20.2 (1.7 points above).

0
A FANDOM User
• 11/25/2013
75.23.234.106 wrote:
Hina sama wrote:
It's true a BMI would say that the characters would be underweight/anorexic, but you have to put into consideration that the series takes place in Japan and people there do tend to weigh less due to their life style and diet.

Also you got to remember, this is a fictional series. So you shouldn't put too much thought into the characters weight or height. ^^;

I know it's fiction but for Nagi and Isumi, it would seem unhealthy for the current weight relative to their height (would a Japanese 13-year old at 138 cm weight 63 pounds in real life without suffering from anorexia). Hayate's is at 20.2 (1.7 points above).

Logically you are right..But just like Hina Sama said there is no need to think about it a all...there could be some faults in the info. or maybe underweight/anorexic was not considered that much.........these things are often avoided....cause that won't affect the important issues of an anime or manga...

Write a reply...